Barney or BJ ?

Last weekend I realised this confused print on the children's favourite mascot character. So I asked Abella : " This is Barney or BJ ?" The confused girl almost say Barney then she paused and replied BJ! I proceed to ask Clarabelle and the confident girl replied "Barney" without much hesitation. I wouldnt say the latter reply is wrong as I think Clarabelle acknowedge the colour but Abella is appearance. Indeed this two girls are different in certain way...

In case those who still cant tell the confusion... check out this picture

Barney is the center character in purple and green whereas BJ is on the right in yellow and green.